Hotelaholic

Edgartown · Massachusetts

Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, an Ascend Collection Hotel

227 Upper Main St, Edgartown, Massachusetts, 02539

8.3 Excellent302 guest reviews

Live availability

Book your stay

Check-in
Nov 24, 2026
Check-out
Nov 26, 2026
Book your stay

HAPPI EXPERIENCE

Welcome to Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, Ascend Hotel Collection!

  • Location & surroundings

    Convenient Location:: Located just 2.1 km from Lighthouse Beach and 1.8 km from Edgartown Lighthouse, our 3-star property offers easy access to popular attractions.

  • At the hotel

    Top-Notch Amenities:: Enjoy our hotel's business centre for your work needs, stay connected with our free WiFi access, and rest easy with complimentary private parking.

  • The stay, in detail

    Traveler-Friendly Services:: With a smoke-free environment and proximity to Martha's Vineyard Airport only 8 km away, your comfort and convenience are our top priorities.

Book now for an unforgettable stay at Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, Ascend Hotel Collection!

HAPPI HIGHLIGHTS

  • Friendly staff

  • Great location

  • Spacious rooms

At the hotel

Popular amenities

30 listed
  • Access to health care professionals
  • Air conditioning
  • Cashless payment available
  • Cleaning standards that are effective against Coronavirus
  • Fire extinguishers
  • First aid kit available
  • Free Parking
  • Free WiFi
  • Guest room sealed after cleaning
  • Guest rooms disinfected between stays
View all amenities

Dining & drinks

  • Physical distancing in dining areas
  • Sanitized tableware & silverware

Rooms & comfort

  • Heating
  • Non-smoking rooms

Safety & cleanliness

  • Guests can opt-out any cleaning services during stay
  • Hand sanitizer in guest room and key areas
  • Physical distancing rules followed
  • Process in place to check health of guests
  • Safety deposit box
  • Screens / Barriers between staff and guests for safety
  • Shared stationery like menus, pens are removed
  • Smoke alarms
  • Staff adhere to local safety protocols

Getting around & access

  • Parking
  • Private parking

Guest services

  • Invoice provided
  • Laundry washed per local authority guidelines

Services & essentials

  • Key card access
  • Non-smoking throughout
  • WiFi available

Review in focus

302 reviews
7/ 10
Location to things was great!
Grant W · solo traveller · 2026-10-07

The guest experience

8.3out of 10
302 verified reviews

Loved most

  • Friendly staff
  • Great location
  • Spacious rooms

Worth knowing — Cleanliness issues · No pool · Breakfast not recommended

How guests scored the stay

  • Location9.3

    The location was praised for its convenience and accessibility.

  • Service9.2

    The staff was described as exceptionally friendly and helpful.

  • Overall Experience8.7

    Overall, most guests had a positive experience with some minor issues.

  • Room Quality8.2

    Rooms were noted as spacious and cozy, albeit with some maintenance issues.

  • Value for Money8.2

    Some guests found the stay to be a bit expensive for the overall experience.

  • Cleanliness7.8

    Several reviews noted cleanliness issues, particularly in the bathroom.

  • Amenities7.8

    Some amenities were good, but some missing elements like a pool were noted.

  • Food and Beverage7.3

    Breakfast options were not recommended, affecting the overall rating in this category.

Live guest feedback

Guest reviews

Mixed experiences

75% of 12 recent stays rated 8+

8.3302 reviews

  • Guest review

    7/10

    Grant W · solo traveller · 2026-10-07

    “Location to things was great!”

  • Staff was friendly and helpful. Room was clean and comfortable

    9/10

    Joan · couple · 2026-09-18

    “Location and room was great”

  • Great place!

    10/10

    Samantha · couple · 2026-09-10

    “Right near town, good restaurant”

  • Good location, clean and simple hotel, but don't get a room above the bar

    6/10

    Stacie · couple · 2026-09-07

    “Location is great, and it's cute and perfectly servicable.”

  • Disappointed

    4/10

    Renita · solo traveller · 2026-09-02

    “1. The room size 2. The decor 3. The deck 4. Had to select the source and HDMI each time we turned the TV on.”

  • Lovely stay for a quick trip!

    10/10

    JaciC1217 · NONE · 2026-08-03

    “We had a lovely time at Edgar Hotel! The staff was extremely nice and helpful. The room was clean and cute, and when we arrived the pack-and-play and extra sheets were already there. We loved the walk to/from town, extremely easy to do with a stroller. And at night, we loved having the Town Tavern right next door for a few drinks. Overall, we were very pleasantly surprised at how much we enjoyed our stay! Thanks again to Eli the manager on our checkout date for letting us have a late checkout - that extra time allowed our little one to nap so we could all enjoy the rest of our day on island before the ferry home.”

  • Perfect!

    10/10

    thomiee · NONE · 2026-07-26

    “Cozy and beautiful location. The lovely weather was the icing on the cake. The hotel lent us beach chairs and towels. ”

  • Guest review

    9/10

    Joseph · family with children · 2026-07-18

    “Rooms were charming and very comfortable. Rooms were ready early.”

  • Guest review

    10/10

    Patrice · family with children · 2026-07-17

    “The staff and clenliness”

  • Nice hotel just outside of Edgartown city center

    8/10

    benz37 · Couples · 2026-07-02

    “My husband and I stayed here for a weekend as one of the hotels for a wedding party. The room was comfortable, clean and spacious, with the usual amenities. It is located about a 20 minute walk from the center of Edgartown and has a large parking area. A restaurant is located on the premises, and the farewell brunch for the wedding was held there, which was quite nice. The price for the room seemed rather high to us, but it's apparently one of the more reasonable hotels on Martha's Vineyard.”

  • Great location to enjoy Edgartown

    9/10

    Palermo · couple · 2026-06-13

    “Beautiful rooms”

  • Comfortable and Clean in a great location near town.

    10/10

    marilyns183 · Family · 2026-06-09

    “We were this is past weekend for a family event. The room was clean and the bed was one of the most comfortable around. The location of our room on the first floor of the main building was quite dark with not a lot of natural sunlight and no outside space - but we were rarely in the room and it wasn't a problem. One suggestion would be to improve the lighting in the bathroom.. It was quite dark, making it difficult to apply makeup for our event. The location of the hotel is on the busy main road and it is mostly parking lot - no green spaces, but it is right next to the Stop and Shop if you need any items. It's a quick walk to downtown Edgartown - which was great, not needing a car for everything. If you are looking for a quiet spot with outdoor space or even a pool, this is not the hotel for you. But for our needs, it fit the bill. We rented a car and drove to the beach and all over the island. I have to give a shout out to the staff. They were outstanding. Every single person we dealt with were so friendly and helpful. They even gave us towels and beach chairs when we told them we were heading to the beach. They were so great!”

View all guest reviews

Hotel info and reviews come from third-party sources.