Name: Montauk Yacht Club
Address: 32 Star Island Rd, Montauk, New York, 11954, US
Rating: 9.2

The stay, in detail

Luxurious Amenities and Services

Located on Star Island in Lake Montauk, Montauk Yacht Club offers a unique blend of elegance and relaxation. With a private beach, 3 swimming pools, and boat rentals, guests can indulge in ultimate leisure. The nautical-themed rooms with private balconies provide a cozy retreat, equipped with modern amenities like flat-screen TVs and free WiFi.

Culinary Delights

Indulge in a culinary journey at the resort's 3 dining options - Showfish, The Pool Club, and Il Forno. From fresh seafood to delectable Italian cuisine, there's something to satisfy every palate.

Recreational Activities

Unwind with spa services, or enjoy outdoor activities like volleyball, tennis, and horseshoes. With Rita’s Horse Stables and Montauk Downs Golf Course nearby, adventure and relaxation await at Montauk Yacht Club.

Book now for an unforgettable stay at Montauk Yacht Club!

Live guest feedback

Guest reviews

Mixed experiences

82% of 11 recent stays rated 8+

9.2422 reviews

Guest review
9/10
Dianne · family with children · 2026-09-16
“We loved the resort; it was amazing, with lots to do and see and a great location. The hotel facilities were great, with amazing food and drink options, and the padel courts were a firm favourite.”
Comfortable, relaxing with great service and amazing views.
10/10
Tracy · extended group · 2026-08-24
“Travelled with my 2 daughters from UK for a Girlie long weekend. Room was perfect for us, 2 double beds, great bathroom and fabulous view. It's a big YES from us!”
Beautiful property, but a very disappointing experience due to the room assignment, unresolved noise
2/10
Abouzar · family with children · 2026-08-13
“The property itself is attractive and well located.”
Above and beyond
10/10
L6042EDrobertl · Family · 2026-07-19
“We had a wonderful experience at the Montauk Yacht Club, and Leo made it even more special. From the moment we arrived, he was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and genuinely helpful. He went above and beyond to make our stay memorable by surprising us with a cake to celebrate our father's 75th birthday. It was such a thoughtful gesture that meant a lot to our family. Exceptional service like this is what makes a place stand out. Thank you, Leo, for your kindness and hospitality—we truly appreciate it and hope to be back again soon!”
Underwhelmed by this poor hotel
2/10
lovemyflipflops · Couples · 2026-07-19
“We are currently stating at MYC and my advice to anyone looking to book this hotel is read the negative reviews. This hotel doesn’t match up to the positive reviews online. It’s a yacht club and the hotel comes as a 2nd and it shows. Reasons below - the rooms are so noisy! All rooms have interconnecting doors so the strangers in the next room might as well be sharing with you, creaky stairs throughout the building, rooms on the lower floor can hear every step from the room above, no sound proofing at all, hearing dogs yapping in rooms on the opposite side of the building. - The rooms are fusty and smell damp. - A double room has 1 chair so where is the other person to sit? Attention to details is poor. - The bathrooms are so badly ventilated that the clothes you hang on the hanging rail get damp from the shower steam. - what you can’t see from the online photos is how many boats are at the marina and all the boat owners have use of the hotel facilities, restaurant and pool as well as the hotel guests which is too many people. The hotel isn’t big enough for this and there aren’t nearly enough places to relax and enjoy the sun. There are approximately 30 sun loungers around the adults pool and once these are taken there is no where else to go. - Our 1st and only evening meal in the restaurants was chaotic. The hotel is staffed by lots of kids on college break and though they are friendly the inexperience shows. It’s also extortionate in price. - When we arrived I asked to change room due to the noise level from the room next door. It wasn’t that they were unusually noisy but it was lack of insulation. The reception guy said all rooms are the same and there wasn’t as option to change other than pay even more. Our room was $1500 per night - that is extortionate for the quality of the room so no way would we have paid more to be in a different room and still be told it would have the same issues and an interconnecting door. - The hotel feels like a motel that’s had an addition of a nicely decorated reception and restaurant but the rooms don’t match the same level. - Pool loungers are stained and very dirty. - Restaurant food is mediocre but ridiculously expensive. Example - the lunchtime fish tacos = 2 tiny tacos with a very small, poor quality piece of fish. Not worth $32!!! - be warned when you check out you will be charged $100 per day water club fee - this is an additional charge to use the pool, tennis court, coffee machine and WiFi. Unbelievable on a supposed 5 star property. This whole hotel experience hasn’t wowed us on any level. It is a joke to charge the extras and expect people to return. Only positive is the concierge lady who books the sightseeing experiences and bike hire ,she is so knowledgeable of the area and the best things to do. Totally underwhelming experience and we would never return.”
Wesley made our day! He was professional and kind and elevated our experience!!
10/10
daniellerA288IK · Family · 2026-07-19
“Wesley was professional & kind and made our day!”
Montauk Yacht Club scores big!
10/10
darrendC2800VT · Family · 2026-07-19
“Great stay!!! Katie (from Galway, in dining) was very, very friendly and very sweet!! Best of luck to her in her future endeavors! Darren and Sharon DeVivo of Dobbs Ferry, New York!”
No yacht needed
10/10
thomasdX7974MM · Couples · 2026-07-15
“MYC is one of the nicer properties in Montauk. The grounds are very well maintained, the rooms are modern and spacious, the pools are clean and properly staffed, the beach is perfect for children, the service is outstanding and the food choices are excellent. MYC is in a quiet location but only a short hop to the harbor area and a quick drive to everything else.”
Very pleasant delightful engaging
10/10
Tourist09105473997 · Family · 2026-07-13
“Very fun and exciting the indoor pool is really fun”
MYC Memory
10/10
T9327FOlaurao · Family · 2026-07-11
“Montauk Yacht Club Perfect place for a wedding Food and service was superb”
Pleasant
10/10
rosemariei667 · Family · 2026-07-11
“Sherlin was pleasant, thorough & tentative. The food is as amazing especially the waffle my daughter enjoyed it. I enjoyed my espresso latte and avocado toast!”

View all guest reviews

Hotel info and reviews come from third-party sources.

Montauk Yacht Club

Book your stay

Book your stay

Book your stay

The stay, in detail

Luxurious Amenities and Services

Culinary Delights

Recreational Activities

Popular amenities

Pools & wellness

Dining & drinks

Fitness & outdoors

Rooms & comfort

Safety & cleanliness

Getting around & access

Guest services

Services & essentials

Guest reviews

Guest review

Comfortable, relaxing with great service and amazing views.

Beautiful property, but a very disappointing experience due to the room assignment, unresolved noise

Above and beyond

Underwhelmed by this poor hotel

Wesley made our day! He was professional and kind and elevated our experience!!

Montauk Yacht Club scores big!

No yacht needed

Very pleasant delightful engaging

MYC Memory

Pleasant

Where to next?