Hotelaholic

Montauk · New York

The Montauk Beach House

55 S Elmwood Ave., Montauk, New York, 11954

Live availability

Book your stay

Check-in
Nov 24, 2026
Check-out
Nov 26, 2026
Book your stay

HAPPI EXPERIENCE

The stay, in detail

  • Luxurious Amenities

    The Montauk Beach House offers an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café, and snack bar. Guests can enjoy cocktails by the poolside and shop for clothing and beauty products at the on-site gift shop.

  • Comfortable Accommodations

    Each air-conditioned guest room features a flat-screen cable TV and a private bathroom with free toiletries. Some rooms even offer a refreshing pool view for a more relaxing stay.

  • Convenient Location

    Situated just off Route 27, the hotel provides easy access to Camp Hero State Park and Hither Hills State Park. With dining options like South Edison within walking distance, guests can explore the area conveniently.

Book your stay at The Montauk Beach House for a perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience.

HAPPI HIGHLIGHTS

  • Good location

  • Friendly staff

  • Modern rooms

At the hotel

Popular amenities

48 listed
  • 24-hour front desk
  • Access to health care professionals
  • Air conditioning
  • Bar
  • BBQ facilities
  • Beach
  • Car hire
  • Cashless payment available
  • Cleaning standards that are effective against Coronavirus
  • Concierge service
View all amenities

Pools & wellness

  • Outdoor pool
  • Swimming pool

Dining & drinks

  • Physical distancing in dining areas
  • Restaurant
  • Snack bar
  • Wine/champagne

Fitness & outdoors

  • Garden
  • Sun terrace
  • Terrace

Rooms & comfort

  • Heating
  • Non-smoking rooms

Safety & cleanliness

  • Contactless check-in/check-out
  • Fire extinguishers
  • First aid kit available
  • Guest room sealed after cleaning
  • Guest rooms disinfected between stays
  • Hand sanitizer in guest room and key areas
  • Physical distancing rules followed
  • Process in place to check health of guests
  • Safety deposit box
  • Screens / Barriers between staff and guests for safety
  • Shared stationery like menus, pens are removed
  • Smoke alarms
  • Staff adhere to local safety protocols

Getting around & access

  • Free Parking
  • Parking
  • Private parking

Guest services

  • Fax/photocopying
  • Laundry washed per local authority guidelines
  • Luggage storage
  • Meeting/banquet facilities
  • Private check-in/check-out

Services & essentials

  • Evening entertainment
  • Face masks for guests available
  • Family rooms
  • Free WiFi
  • Nightclub/DJ
  • WiFi available

Review in focus

142 reviews
7/ 10
Close to the plaza
Scott · family with children · 2026-08-05

The guest experience

8.4out of 10
142 verified reviews

Loved most

  • Good location
  • Friendly staff
  • Modern rooms

Worth knowing — Rude staff · Pool maintenance · Value for money

How guests scored the stay

  • Location9.5

    Consistently praised for great location near attractions.

  • Service9.3

    Generally positive service experiences, though some staff were mentioned as rude.

  • Overall Experience8.9

    Mixed experiences, but overall satisfaction about aspects like location and service.

  • Food and Beverage8.7

    Food was positively remarked upon at the bar, but some inconsistencies in service noted.

  • Room Quality8.4

    Rooms were modern and clean but some concerns about amenities.

  • Cleanliness8.0

    Clean room but overall cleanliness mentioned negatively in reviews about the shower and pool.

  • Amenities7.5

    Pool maintenance issues and lack of coffee and water in rooms noted.

Live guest feedback

Guest reviews

Mixed experiences

47% of 15 recent stays rated 8+

8.4142 reviews
  • Stay somewhere else with direct beach access

    7/10

    Scott · family with children · 2026-08-05

    “Close to the plaza”

  • There’s no condition for the guests, only the pool is best part

    5/10

    Айгерим · extended group · 2026-07-10

    “Just pool”

  • The Montauk Beach Hotel is a both hip and cozy between the beach and town.

    9/10

    Evans · couple · 2026-01-19

    “I didn't have breakfast, but a great cappuccino at 8 AM The Montauk Beach House has artistic flair. It's laid out beautifully and the property is walking distance from restaurants and art exhibits on the square. The staff is super friendly. We checked in at 10:00 PM and someone was still there to great us. I loved it. The rooms are super clean and cozy with balconies.”

  • Below average for the price

    2/10

    Caley · couple · 2025-09-15

    “Good location”

  • Guest review

    4/10

    Noelle · partner · 2025-09-14

    “Property pics and description makes u think your on the water. No water view at all anywhere. Booked $700 a night and found same room cheaper $400. I feel taken. The coffee shop doesn’t open until 8am. Pool closes early and it’s very noisy. Super disappointed 😔 ”

  • Guest review

    10/10

    Flora · partner · 2025-09-13

    “Loved it. Cant wait to go back”

  • It wouldn't take much effort to make it really great

    6/10

    Gemma Fox · couple · 2025-09-08

    “Great coffee and love the maiden grass. The young woman with the red hair was very sweet to us.”

  • Loved the resort and its amenities. Rooms were very modern and clean. Staff were friendly. Just because they are not as

    8/10

    LaScala · extended group · 2025-08-30

    “Beautiful grounds clean and modern”

  • Unpleasant staff and poor property upkeep do not make for s great stsy

    3/10

    Lily · extended group · 2025-08-28

    “Great location, excellent bar and food.”

  • Perfect location and service.

    9/10

    Victoria · couple · 2025-08-09

    “The service, location and flexibility.”

  • Guest review

    10/10

    heather · 2025-08-07

    “Super staff and beautiful location!”

  • Guest review

    6/10

    Christine · family · 2025-08-07

    “Nice staff, quaint spot with a good location. We had to leave a day early bc my daughter was quite sick. No allowances were given which wasn't great. Loud music by the pool was a bit much with young kids.”

  • Guest review

    10/10

    Justyna · family · 2025-08-03

    “Had a wonderful and peaceful time. Great location, walkable everywhere. Loved the landscaping and the vibe. Was wondering if only our room didn’t have a small refrigerator or others too. That was the only part missing”

  • I would not stay here again.

    4/10

    Jacob · couple · 2025-08-02

    “The room was clean.”

  • Guest review

    9/10

    Frank · family with children · 2025-08-02

    “Very attentive staff. Decoration and setting were amazing definitely worth the fee. Look forward to going back. Couldn't be better located walk score 10”

Hotel info and reviews come from third-party sources.