Hotelaholic

Sag Harbor · New York

Faraway Sag Harbor

31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, 11963

Live availability

Book your stay

Check-in
Nov 24, 2026
Check-out
Nov 26, 2026
Book your stay

HAPPI EXPERIENCE

The stay, in detail

  • Luxurious Accommodations

    Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor offers elegantly furnished guest rooms equipped with modern amenities, including flat-screen TVs and luxurious bathrobes. Select rooms even provide stunning views of the sea or garden, ensuring a memorable stay.

  • Gourmet Dining Experience

    Indulge in a culinary journey at the on-site restaurant, where you can savor fresh American cuisine for lunch and dinner daily. Treat yourself to a delightful breakfast and brunch on the weekends, promising a delectable start to your day.

  • Leisure and Activities

    From relaxing by the seasonal saltwater swimming pool to exploring the picturesque surroundings on a bike hired from the hotel, Baron's Cove provides ample opportunities for leisure and recreation. The 24-hour front desk is always ready to assist, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable stay.

Book your stay at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor today for a luxurious and unforgettable experience.

HAPPI HIGHLIGHTS

  • Great location

  • Friendly staff

  • Comfortable amenities

At the hotel

Popular amenities

93 listed
  • 24-hour front desk
  • 24-hour security
  • Accessible parking
  • Aerobics
  • Air conditioning
  • Allergy-free room
  • Babysitting/child services
  • Bar
  • Beach
  • Bike tours
View all amenities

Pools & wellness

  • Heated pool
  • Massage services
  • Outdoor pool
  • Outdoor pool - seasonal
  • Pool with view
  • Spa/wellness center
  • Swimming pool

Dining & drinks

  • Breakfast in the room
  • Coffee Shop on site
  • Fruits
  • Kid meals
  • Restaurant
  • Sanitized tableware & silverware
  • Snack bar
  • Special diet menus - on request
  • Wine/champagne

Fitness & outdoors

  • Cycling
  • Fitness center
  • Fitness classes
  • Fitness facilities
  • Garden
  • Outdoor fireplace
  • Outdoor furniture
  • Sun loungers or beach chairs
  • Sun terrace
  • Terrace
  • Water sport facilities on site
  • Yoga classes

Rooms & comfort

  • CCTV in common areas
  • CCTV outside property
  • Heating
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Shared lounge/TV area
  • Soundproof rooms

Safety & cleanliness

  • Cleaning standards that are effective against Coronavirus
  • Dry cleaning
  • Entertainment staff
  • Fire extinguishers
  • Guest rooms disinfected between stays
  • Guests can opt-out any cleaning services during stay
  • Hand sanitizer in guest room and key areas
  • Safety deposit box
  • Security alarm
  • Shared stationery like menus, pens are removed
  • Smoke alarms
  • Staff adhere to local safety protocols

Getting around & access

  • Facilities for disabled guests
  • Free Parking
  • Lift / Elevator
  • Parking
  • Private parking
  • Street parking
  • Valet parking

Guest services

  • Concierge service
  • Express check-in/check-out
  • Fax/photocopying
  • Invoice provided
  • Ironing service
  • Laundry
  • Laundry washed per local authority guidelines
  • Luggage storage
  • Meeting/banquet facilities
  • Pets allowed
  • Private check-in/check-out
  • Tour desk

Services & essentials

  • Board games/puzzles
  • Business center
  • Canoeing
  • Cashless payment available
  • Daily housekeeping
  • Designated smoking area
  • Electric vehicle charging station
  • Evening entertainment
  • Family rooms
  • Fishing
  • Free WiFi
  • Key access
  • Key card access
  • Live music/performance
  • Non-smoking throughout
  • Packed lunches
  • Sun umbrellas
  • WiFi available

Review in focus

253 reviews
3/ 10
Pequena e estrutura incompativel com preço
Juliana · couple · 2026-09-03

The guest experience

8.9out of 10
253 verified reviews

Loved most

  • Great location
  • Friendly staff
  • Comfortable amenities
  • Good food and beverage options
  • Relaxing atmosphere

Worth knowing — Musty smells in rooms · Some staffing issues reported · Limited food availability at times

How guests scored the stay

  • Location9.5

    Consistently praised as convenient and charming; very walkable.

  • Amenities9.5

    Amenities were highlighted positively, including the pool and restaurant.

  • Service9.4

    Staff is noted as friendly and attentive, providing a good overall service experience.

  • Food and Beverage9.0

    Food quality was praised, though some items were unavailable.

  • Overall Experience8.9

    General consensus reflects a pleasant stay with some minor issues.

  • Room Quality8.4

    Mixed reviews on room quality with mentions of mustiness but also comfort.

  • Value for Money8.4

    Some complaints regarding pricing, but overall good value for quality.

  • Cleanliness8.0

    Several reviews mentioned musty smells and issues with room cleanliness.

Live guest feedback

Guest reviews

Mixed experiences

55% of 11 recent stays rated 8+

8.9253 reviews
  • Custo benefício pessimo, nao vale a pena

    3/10

    Juliana · couple · 2026-09-03

    “Pequena e estrutura incompativel com preço”

  • Funcionarios da recepcao e do cafe da manha nos trataram c descaso

    6/10

    Fabio · couple · 2026-09-03

    “A cama”

  • Non lo suggerirei…

    6/10

    Stella · family with children · 2026-08-15

    “Molto bella la piscina e l’utilizzo gratuito delle biciclette. Posizione centrale ma allo stesso tempo tranquillo. Hotel arredato con stile!! Molto stile! Ma camera da letto deludente. Con affaccio sul parcheggio - stile Motel americano. Per il Costo dell’hotel sono rimasta molto delusa!”

  • Lovely stay but way over priced for services

    8/10

    Reem · couple · 2026-06-27

    “Lovely design and decoration of period buildings and port cabins. I liked the cafe area and bar and the mattresses were very comfortable.”

  • Very relaxing!

    9/10

    Charies J · couple · 2026-06-24

    “Very Nice.”

  • Guest review

    10/10

    Katherine · 2025-10-01

    “Parking was free and really easy. Great proximity to the main street of town—you can easily walk, but it's not too close where it gets loud at night. The front staff and cleaning team were all lovely and super helpful. We loved the coffee bar in the mornings. ”

  • Guest review

    8/10

    andrew · partner · 2025-09-25

    “staff seemed tired and fed up of people staying!”

  • Guest review

    10/10

    Ivonne · 2025-09-24

    “Quaint hotel in town. It’s perfect!”

  • Guest review

    6/10

    richard · 2025-09-21

    “Very standard Not an extra bottle of water Nothing more than what is offered Basic, just fine ”

  • Guest review

    4/10

    john · partner · 2025-09-20

    “Sadly in need of a renovation. Extremely poor value but front desk staff was super nice. You will be underwhelmed by the rooms. The “garden rooms” overlook the parking lot. I would not stay there again. ”

  • Sag Harbour Top!

    8/10

    Marano · couple · 2025-08-26

View all guest reviews

Hotel info and reviews come from third-party sources.