Five-star
The five-star edit
9.201Montauk Yacht Club32 Star Island RdExplore hotel 
8.802Montauk Manor236 Edgemere St.Explore hotel 
8.803Topping Rose HouseOne Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor TurnpikeExplore hotel 
8.404The Montauk Beach House55 S Elmwood Ave.Explore hotel 
8.205The Montauk Soundview6 Soundview DriveExplore hotel 
7.806Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa290 Old Montauk HighwayExplore hotel
Four-star
Four-star favorites
9.201Hero Beach Club626 Montauk HwyExplore hotel 
9.002Journey East Hampton490 Pantigo RoadExplore hotel 
8.703Marram21 Oceanview TerraceExplore hotel 
8.504Southampton Inn91 Hill StreetExplore hotel 
8.205The Maidstone Hotel207 Main StreetExplore hotel 
4.006Offshore MontaukExplore hotel 
07Ruschmeyers #15 - Dlx Queen161 Second House Rd.Explore hotel
Ready when you are
Check dates in The Hamptons
Check live availability in The Hamptons, USA
Hotel info and reviews come from third-party sources.